Post by Ethan Hawkeye on Sept 13, 2004 19:03:37 GMT -5
The outcome is finally in, Hawkeye won first place with a 25.5/30 then Ghost came second with a 24/30 and BDR was not far behind with a 23/30 it was a close competition and the results and graphics are now posted on the site.
![]()
a.1asphost.com/hawkgames/newlayout/graphics/chars/goblinHAWKEYE.png
[/img]
![]()
a.1asphost.com/hawkgames/newlayout/graphics/chars/goblinGHOST.png
[/img]
![]()
a.1asphost.com/hawkgames/newlayout/graphics/chars/goblinBDR.png
[/img]
COMMENTS:
For Hawkeye:
~ Firstly, what kind of a deplorable jackass enters their own contest? Moving on, I thought this one possessed most of the positive qualities which the other two lacked (although it still doesn't have the shadow in ghost's charset, tisk tisk). It follows the criteria, it's nicely drawn, what more could you ask for? The only aspects that seemed questionable were the shape of its head, and the well-doneness of the side movements. With some touching up, it could be something you'd find in an RTP (but better, do to its non-crapiness). By the way, I personally LOVE the earring!
~ Hawkeye is good, but the face is to dark compared to the rest of the body
~ Nice Job!
For Ghost:
~ You should follow the guidelines a bit more carefully next time and that's the only reason your points were deducted.
~ Great job overall, but you didn't follow the instructions properly and lost points for that.
~ Extremely well-drawn, but it just wasn't my thing. It was too tall and too uhh, blue to be a goblin. One thing it had that no one else's did was a shadow though. What can I really say? It was great, and would have won by a mile if maybe the contest was for a dark elf or something. Ghost really shows promise with this charset.
For BDR:
~ Yours was by far my most favorite and deserves to win, but it seems done very quickly. It's great work for self-made and got top marks by me.
~ Wasn't that appealing to me and could have had more effort put into it, but I did like the cartoon feel of your work.
~ BDR, as usual, delivers something of a very cartoonish nature, incredible for something that was drawn from scratch... but where are the ears?!?
[/img]
[/img]
[/img]
COMMENTS:
For Hawkeye:
~ Firstly, what kind of a deplorable jackass enters their own contest? Moving on, I thought this one possessed most of the positive qualities which the other two lacked (although it still doesn't have the shadow in ghost's charset, tisk tisk). It follows the criteria, it's nicely drawn, what more could you ask for? The only aspects that seemed questionable were the shape of its head, and the well-doneness of the side movements. With some touching up, it could be something you'd find in an RTP (but better, do to its non-crapiness). By the way, I personally LOVE the earring!
~ Hawkeye is good, but the face is to dark compared to the rest of the body
~ Nice Job!
For Ghost:
~ You should follow the guidelines a bit more carefully next time and that's the only reason your points were deducted.
~ Great job overall, but you didn't follow the instructions properly and lost points for that.
~ Extremely well-drawn, but it just wasn't my thing. It was too tall and too uhh, blue to be a goblin. One thing it had that no one else's did was a shadow though. What can I really say? It was great, and would have won by a mile if maybe the contest was for a dark elf or something. Ghost really shows promise with this charset.
For BDR:
~ Yours was by far my most favorite and deserves to win, but it seems done very quickly. It's great work for self-made and got top marks by me.
~ Wasn't that appealing to me and could have had more effort put into it, but I did like the cartoon feel of your work.
~ BDR, as usual, delivers something of a very cartoonish nature, incredible for something that was drawn from scratch... but where are the ears?!?
